[<prev] [next>] [<thread-prev] [thread-next>] [day] [month] [year] [list]
Message-ID: <29515774624.20021223121055@planetolsen.com>
Date: Mon, 23 Dec 2002 12:10:55 -0600
From: James Olsen <jamesml@...netolsen.com>
To: popa3d-users@...ts.openwall.com
Subject: Re[2]: Question about using popa3d and stunnel
Hello Solar,
Thank you for your very quick reply!
SD> All I can say is that people are using popa3d with stunnel and it
SD> works.
SD> The setup that we use at work is based around a patched ancient
SD> version of stunnel, so I am unable to post a sample configuration
SD> myself, but I hope someone else will.
SD> Also, a Google search for "stunnel popa3d" gives pointers to quite a
SD> few other mailing list discussions on this topic, some with sample
SD> configurations.
I've found some references to pop3d and stunnel, but they all seem to
use older versions of stunnel that relied heavily on command-line
options. Even the stunnel.org website (granted, not officially part of
stunnel) documentation and examples are for older versions of stunnel.
The newest version has minimal command-line options and instead has
the configuration in a text file. I've tried to translate the examples
I've seen for the new configuration but I've not done something right.
SD> It's a really good idea to have stunnel running as a dedicated
SD> pseudo-user (I don't know if this still requires patching, it used
SD> to). There have been numerous security holes discovered in both
SD> stunnel itself and in OpenSSL that it uses.
I attempted to run it as an unprivileged user/group but ran into
permission problems (see logs below). However, the service is only up
for testing for brief periods of time and will ultimately run as
unprivleged user/group once all these issues are worked out.
I wonder how problems running stunnel as a regular user/group may a
problem since popa3d wants to do it's own setuid and setgid and
chroot.
SD> Well, someone might be able to help you if you posted your
SD> configuration (both server and client).
Sorry :) Here is the info:
Output of "stunnel -V":
stunnel 4.03 on i686-pc-linux-gnu PTHREAD+LIBWRAP with OpenSSL 0.9.6h 5 Dec 2002
Output of "uname -a":
Linux planetolsen 2.4.18 #2 Wed Sep 11 18:12:03 CDT 2002 i686 unknown
libc version: I must confess, I'm not sure if this is right:
/lib/libc-2.2.5.so
Output of "gcc -v":
gcc version 2.95.3 20010315 (release)
I'm using version 0.5.1 of popa3d (latest stable release). I don't
know what has been changed/implemented in any of the stable or the
development releases, there doesn't seem to be any kind of change-log
or revision history on the openwall.com website or in the tarballs.
:(
Here is my configuration file I use when starting stunnel:
=======================
cert=/usr/local/ssl/stunnel.pem
debug=debug
output=/usr/local/ssl/stunnel.out
setgid=unpriv
setuid=unpriv
[pop3s]
#protocol=pop3
accept=995
exec=/usr/local/sbin/popa3d
execargs=popa3d
=======================
Given the above configuration, I get the following message in the
logs:
=======================
Dec 23 10:22:18 www popa3d[22756]: chroot: Permission denied
=======================
popa3d is trying to chroot to /var/empty (the default, which is
compiled into the program)
I'm "newbie" enough I'm not sure how to set this up to work properly
as an unprivileged user. But /var/empty I believe is supposed to be
read/writable only by root if I read the popa3d documentation
properly. Doesn't this rule out running stunnel as an unprivileged
user?
But, in the meantime, to make sure the rest of my configuration is
okay I am temporarily letting it run as root (fire it up, test, shut
it down). And when doing so, the permission denied error goes away and
then I'm faced with this message:
=======================
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23964:1024]: pop3s accepted FD=5 from 207.56.32.235:3646
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23964:1024]: FD 5 in non-blocking mode
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: pop3s started
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG5[23970:1026]: pop3s connected from 207.56.32.235:3646
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): before/accept initialization
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 read client hello A
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 write server hello A
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 write certificate A
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 write server done A
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 flush data
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 read client key exchange A
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 read finished A
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 write change cipher spec A
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 write finished A
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL state (accept): SSLv3 flush data
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 1 items in the session cache
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 0 client connects (SSL_connect())
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 0 client connects that finished
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 0 client renegotiatations requested
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 1 server connects (SSL_accept())
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 1 server connects that finished
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 0 server renegotiatiations requested
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 0 session cache hits
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 0 session cache misses
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: 0 session cache timeouts
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG6[23970:1026]: Negotiated ciphers: DES-CBC3-SHA SSLv3 Kx=RSA Au=RSA Enc=3DES(168) Mac=SHA1
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG6[23970:1026]: Local mode child started (PID=23971)
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: Remote FD=10 initialized
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: SSL socket closed on SSL_read
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG5[23970:1026]: Connection closed: 5 bytes sent to SSL, 0 bytes sent to socket
2002.12.23 10:52:54 LOG7[23970:1026]: pop3s finished (0 left)
Dec 23 10:52:54 www popa3d[23971]: Didn't attempt authentication
=======================
My email client is TheBat, which natively supports TLS connections to
port 995 (also STARTTLS on port 110) and supports four authentication methods:
Regular, MSN (NTLM), MD5 APOP challenge/response (RFC-1734), and MD5
CRAM-HMAC challenge/response (RFC-2095).
By default, I'm using "regular", which works just fine with regular
POP3. I also tried MSN (NTLM) just to see if it worked, and it failed
as well. I'm fairly certain that TheBat will still attempt to
authenticate - I believe something else has failed and because of that
failure the connection terminates before authentication takes place
and that is why I'm getting a "didn't attempt authentication"
messages.
I'm willing to try a different email client (that is known to work
with stunnel/popa3d) to rule out my email client as the problem if
anyone has any suggestions on what would be good one(s) to try.
I've also tried using the "protocol=pop3" configuration in the stunnel
config file, but then I get this series of messages in the logs:
=======================
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22920:1024]: pop3s accepted FD=5 from 207.56.32.235:3621
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22920:1024]: FD 5 in non-blocking mode
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: pop3s started
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG5[22922:1026]: pop3s connected from 207.56.32.235:3621
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG6[22922:1026]: Local mode child started (PID=22923)
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: Remote FD=10 initialized
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: Negotiations for pop3(server side) started
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=10, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=10, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=10, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=10, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=10, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: <- +OK.
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=write
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: -> +OK. + stunnel..
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: FD=5, DIR=read
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: waitforsocket: ok
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: <- ...
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG3[22922:1026]: Client does not want TLS
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG3[22922:1026]: Protocol negotiations failed
2002.12.23 10:33:53 LOG7[22922:1026]: pop3s finished (-1 left)
=======================
Thanks in for your everyone's help... It is greatly appreciated!
--James
Powered by blists - more mailing lists
Confused about mailing lists and their use?
Read about mailing lists on Wikipedia
and check out these
guidelines on proper formatting of your messages.
